The Columbus Crew have had success at times, stress the at times in previous Superdrafts.
Former Head Coach Robert Warzycha had a magic potion in 2011, 2012 when he landed both Justin Meram and Ethan Finlay in a row.
Hire back whichever scout was responsible for that.
Yet, as MLS usually does, sounded a bit too rosy in their article on the discussion, link here.
Here's a better overall for the timeline.